Reported Misconduct Committed By Judge Timothy M. Boudewyns In Rhode Island
Reported Misconduct Committed By Judge Timothy M. Boudewyns In Rhode Island

Judge Boudewyns Was Reported To Lack Objectivity

Jump To Misconduct Listings or Search This Site

Complaint One

Case 94-0436P Garganta v Union Central . Complaint filed by Mr. Garganta, the Pro Se Plaintiff. Magistrate Boudewyns and Judge Pettine made it impossible for Mr. Garganta to have a fair breach of contract trial because of the following:

  • Mr. Garganta was not allowed to show the jury the evidence submitted to Union Central on the claim.
  • Mr. Garganta was not allowed to show the jury the evidence rejected by Union Central on Mr. Garganta's claim.
  • Mr. Garganta was not allowed to show the jury the evidence required by Mr. Garganta's policy with Union Central.
  • Mr. Garganta was not allowed a brief extension of time after his only medical expert witness became ill.
  • Any testimony from Mr. Garganta's witnesses could not be about the excluded evidence mentioned above.
  • All procedures set up by the State of Rhode Island regarding legal proof of disability and procedures for establishing the existence of a disability were ignored by the District Court and were not allowed to be part of Mr. Garganta's breach of contract trial.
  • The Federal District Court disregarded the proof of loss requirements and other contractual agreements between Union Central and Mr. Garganta.

The District Court's reasoning was the evidence eliminated from the trial was irrelevant and prejudicial to the insurance company. Magistrate Boudewyns and Judge Pettine acted in collusion with and assisted Union Central in breaching their contractual obligations with Mr. Garganta. A close analysis of this case will reveal nothing short of institutionalized, court sponsored insurance fraud. The District Court's handling of this case was a setup guaranteeing a loss for Mr. Garganta.

Complaint Two

See complaint filed by Citizen Don Gill [Case Gill v Rhode Island 94-0331B] asserting complete manipulation of civil procedure, judicial bias, judicial intimidation, unauthorized practice of law, altered transcripts and manipulation and denial of due process and other civil rights. This case is a classic example of the shenanigans Citizens without influence experience in Rhode Island courts.

Some comments: 3 different lawyers familiar with Federal District Court have told those involved with that they would not want Magistrate Judge Boudewyns to try a case for them. 2 of these lawyers said outright they would not trust the Magistrate's objectivity. The third lawyer expressed being "uncomfortable" with the Magistrate, particularly when the case involves the "little guy" against the "big guy." As was told to

"The Magistrate has serious problems with objectivity. The Magistrate believes "official duty" and "judicial efficiency" involves superimposing his idea of how a case should go into every aspect of a case. The Magistrate's rulings and reasoning are more affected by his view on how a case should go instead of being based on objectivity, law and facts. The Magistrate's bias in favor of the large insurance company was obvious from the start of my proceedings. In denying me summary judgment, the Magistrate created his own non-factual arguments. While some may think this a stretch, one word that comes to mind in describing the Magistrate is "pampered" by the system."


Many times the reason or purpose for events in our life initially escapes us,
but I am certain we can find reason and/or purpose in everything that happens!

It takes a short time to learn to exercise power, but a lifetime to learn how to avoid abusing it.

We are no longer a country of laws, we are a country where laws are "creatively interpreted."

This site is not free, it takes time and money. Please help!
Donate online NOW
Due to volume, we only deal with electronic communications now (email).

Caught.Net | Pro Se Way | Handling Judges | Secret Canons | Trial Handbook | Bad Judges | Bad Lawyers | Legal Abuse Syndrome | Aggrieved Citizens List


Learn How To Represent Yourself In Court!

Is Gay Prejudice Taught In The Bible?
Tithing - Fact vs. Fiction

Checked with CSE HTML Validator